Writing a journal article critique

Authors need to know what they have done well and not just what they have done poorly.

Tips for writing your first scientific literature review article

Give reasons for your decision. Is the article well-written?

Literary Journal Submissions 101

This system was gradually augmented with using a sharp stylus to indicate what was being counted by means of pictographs. Reject in current form, but allow resubmission of a substantially different version.

Back in the days when everyone was old and stupid or young and foolish and me and Sugar were the only ones just right, this lady moved on our block with nappy hair and proper speech and no makeup. State the objectives clearly as to what is to be obtained. Many students fail to complete this task, as they simply provide a summary of the analyzed paper, writing a journal article critique about personal approach and challenging your own skills and knowledge.

Number all comments, to make it easy for the author to refer to them in correspondence with the editor. These mistakes may include: This template has been designed in collaboration with Overleaf to make it easier for you and your co-authors to write and submit your papers online.

Answer questions in your critique, such as "Is the word choice interesting, appropriate and compelling?

Qualitative Article Critique

So, an article critique is a kind of feedback a student offers after reading an article. Have the authors and you jointly published an article in the past 5 years?

Article critique

Dad was so sure a posse of federal investigators was on our trail that he smoked his unfiltered cigarettes from the wrong end. Then, start presenting specific comments on the paper. In that form, it might have sold a few thousand copies.

Welcome to the Purdue OWL

Now, during your revision, go deeper. This recommendation should be used when the reviewer believes that satisfactory resolution to his or her concerns is possible and that the achievement of successful resolution will result in an acceptable manuscript.

The longest I've written was about five pages, and the shortest was about 10 lines. If you are not going to reject the paper, obtain a copy of a recent issue of the journal, or a paper from a recent issue, to check on formatting of headings, tables, figures, references.

Also, references to unpublished work, to documents in the grey literature technical reportsor to any source that the reader will have difficulty finding or understanding should be avoided. Many students decide to download such samples in order to get an overall idea of how the assignment should look like and what key points should be added.

Linear Bthe writing system of the Mycenaean Greeks[12] has been deciphered while Linear A has yet to be deciphered. Comment on the main idea of the text. When writing a journal, it is good to know that a journal can be classified in various ways.

You have to back off, calm down, see other points of view, maybe even take some responsibility for whatever happened.One of the most popular formatting styles, while completing an article critique is American Psychological Association (APA) format, which has its specific rules and guidelines.

How to review a paper

Your paper should be double-spaced, using 1-inch margins and Times New Roman font in 12 point. The Purdue Writing Lab Purdue University students, faculty, and staff at our West Lafayette, IN campus may access this area for information on the award-winning Purdue Writing Lab.

This area includes Writing Lab hours, services, and contact information. When I undertook the task of writing a scientific literature review article last year, I had hoped that a Google search would reveal a handful of how-to pages thoughtfully created by veterans of this particular writing.

Do you obsess about the tone of your writing as you revise? You should. Tone is one of the most overlooked elements of writing. It can create interest, or kill it. Journal-specific instructions. When you sit down to write the review, make sure you familiarize yourself with any journal-specific guidelines (these will be noted in the journal’s guide for authors available on each journal’s homepage).

First read the article. Before you spend considerable time and energy writing a law review article, make sure that you are covering new ground. Use the following Westlaw databases to determine whether articles on Once you’ve finished researching and writing your law review or journal article, use Westlaw to make sure you’ve accurately quoted and cited the.

Writing a journal article critique
Rated 5/5 based on 16 review